“The road to success and greatness is always paved with consistent hard work. Outwork your competitors, be authentic, and above all else, chase your greatness.”

- Dwayne Johnson

In our commitment to maintaining transparency with our community, we've released a breakdown of the scoring of our recent Hackathon, Pioneer Season 2.

Below is a breakdown of the judges' scoring.

The scores were determined by average the ratings of the judges and the community.

Project

James

Jason

Lew

Bobby

MetaCraft

2

1

6

2

KardiaChain NFT Marketplace

2

2

5

4

Rafflable

6

5

6

7

Hitaya_Chain

3

2

5

5

ALMIGHT

5

5

7

7

PredictRam Defi

7

7

8

9

Robin Mania

4

2

7

6

AgroChain

5

4

5

7

KardiaChain War Alpha

6

3

8

7

GrowLimitless

9

9

9

9

Medblock

7

7

8

10

Aboat Entertainment

10

10

9.5

9

Kardia Bridge

7

5

7

6

KardiaChain Mobile Decentralized Storage

5

3

7

4

RCX NFT Market

0

0

9

7

Solushare

1

1

0

2

Space Invaders

2

0

5

3

Wize - Gig Economy

3

4

7

2

gINFO

7

4

7

5

TaiShang

4

2

9

4

Polyecho

5

3

9

3

Contracto

5

3

7

6

Spense

7

6

9

5

Crediall

8

5

9

5

 

As seen in the breakdown above, each judge had a different evaluation of each project.

For ease of explanation, these votes for each project have been converted to a scale from 1 to 10. As previously indicated, we will use equivalent ratios to calculate the community score.

 

Let's first analyze the results of the received poll:

Project

Votes

Aboat Entertainment

34

ALMIGHT

59

Contracto

3

Crediall

1

gINFO

161

GrowLimitless

13

Hitaya_Chain

21

Kardia Bridge

9

KardiaChain Mobile Decentralized Storage

32

KardiaChain NFT Marketplace

35

KardiaChain War Alpha

5

Medblock

49

MetaCraft

16

Polyecho

14

PredictRam

35

Rafflable

14

RCX NFT Market

1

Robin Mania

16

Solushare

1

Space Invaders

22

Wize - Gig Economy

2

Grand Total

543

 

Now, these votes for each project have been converted to a scale from 1 to 10. As previously indicated, we will use equivalent ratios to calculate the community score.

 

Project

Votes

% of Votes

Normalized

(1-10)

Final Score

Aboat Entertainment

34

6.261510129

2.0625

3

ALMIGHT

59

10.86556169

3.625

4

Contracto

3

0.5524861878

0.125

1

Crediall

1

0.1841620626

0

1

gINFO

161

29.65009208

9.999999999

10

GrowLimitless

13

2.394106814

0.75

1

Hitaya_Chain

21

3.867403315

1.25

2

Kardia Bridge

9

1.657458564

0.5

1

KardiaChain Mobile Decentralized Storage

32

5.893186004

1.9375

2

KardiaChain NFT Marketplace

35

6.445672192

2.125

3

KardiaChain War Alpha

5

0.9208103131

0.25

1

Medblock

49

9.023941068

3

3

MetaCraft

16

2.946593002

0.9375

1

Polyecho

14

2.578268877

0.8125

1

PredictRam

35

6.445672192

2.125

3

Rafflable

14

2.394106814

0.75

1

RCX NFT Market

1

0.1841620626

0

1

Robin Mania

16

2.946593002

0.9375

1

Solushare

1

0.1841620626

0

1

Space Invaders

22

4.051565378

1.3125

2

Wize - Gig Economy

2

0.3683241252

0.0625

1

Grand Total

543

100

33.875

34

Notice how unfair the scoring system described above is?  This bias is a result of gINFO being the only project on KardiaChain ANDhas an active community that is aware of the Pioneer Program.

To illustrate how unfair the preceding scores are, RCX received one vote and received a score of one. RobinMania garnered 16 votes, but their community score remained unchanged at 1.

Clearly, the aforementioned shift of ratings causes a disadvantage for the other projects as it suppresses the community input.


To make it fairer, we awarded gINFO a community score of 10/10 and took the percentage of votes for projects other than gINFO.

 

Project

Votes

% of Votes

Normalized

Final Score

Aboat Entertainment

34

8.90052356

5.689655174

6

ALMIGHT

59

15.44502618

10

10

Contracto

3

0.7853403141

0.3448275863

1

Crediall

1

0.2617801047

0

1

GrowLimitless

13

3.403141361

2.068965518

2

Hitaya_Chain

21

5.497382199

3.448275863

3

Kardia Bridge

9

2.356020942

1.379310345

1

KardiaChain Mobile Decentralized Storage

32

8.376963351

5.344827587

5

KardiaChain NFT Marketplace

35

9.162303665

5.862068967

6

KardiaChain War Alpha

5

1.308900524

0.6896551726

1

Medblock

49

12.82722513

8.275862071

8

MetaCraft

16

4.188481675

2.586206897

3

Polyecho

14

3.664921466

2.241379311

2

PredictRam

35

9.162303665

5.862068967

6

Rafflable

14

3.403141361

2.068965518

2

RCX NFT Market

1

0.2617801047

0

1

Robin Mania

16

4.188481675

2.586206897

3

Solushare

1

0.2617801047

0

1

Space Invaders

22

5.759162304

3.620689656

4

Wize - Gig Economy

2

0.5235602094

0.1724137931

1

Grand Total

382

100

65.68965519

66

 

After careful deliberation, the above scores look more fairly distributed and represent the voice of the community.

After combining the votes of the community and the judges, we obtained the following results:



Project

Category

Score Total

Aboat Entertainment

Other Web 3.0 Applications

44.5

Medblock

Social Goods and Community Engagement Projects

40

GrowLimitless

Tools & Analytics

38

PredictRam Defi

DeFi Dapp

37

ALMIGHT

Web 2 to Web 3 Tools

34

gINFO

Critical Infrastructure Projects

33

Spense

Web 2 to Web 3 Tools

27

Crediall

DeFi Dapp

27

Raffalable

NFT platform

26

Kardia Bridge

Critical Infrastructure Projects

26

KardiaChain War Alpha

GameFi & Metaverse

25

KardiaChain Mobile Decentralized Storage

Other Web 3.0 Applications

24

Robin Mania

GameFi & Metaverse

22

Polyecho

NFT platform

22

AgroChain

DeFi Dapp

21

Contracto

DeFi Dapp

21

Wize - Gig Economy

NFT platform

20

KardiaChain NFT Marketplace

NFT platform

19

TaiShang

Web 2 to Web 3 Tools

19

Hitaya_Chain

DeFi Dapp

18

RCX NFT Market

NFT platform

16

MetaCraft

GameFi & Metaverse

14

Space Invaders

GameFi & Metaverse

10

Solushare

Social Goods and Community Engagement Projects

4

 

And hence, the following results were decided:

winners 4

winners 3

winners 5

 

----


We recognize that this may not be the best way to integrate community consideration or evaluate projects, but we are still evolving and learning. As we move forward with future hackathons, we will have a more rigorous judging method and a larger prize pool.

Congratulations again to the winners of the Hackathon Pioneer Season 2 Program.

We hope this clarifies the community's questions, and we look forward to more victories with the KardiaChain Community on this journey with a single objective in mind: Web3 Mass Adoption.

 

Leave Comment